
Image to help understand the article
Restricting students' smartphone use during the school day may produce academic gains equivalent to one to two additional weeks of learning each year, according to a Harvard-led study released Nov. 17.
The research analyzed standardized test results from approximately 3.3 million students across 4,600 U.S. schools between the 2021-22 and 2025-26 academic years. Researchers from Harvard University's Center for Education Policy Research, Dartmouth College and nonprofit assessment organization NWEA examined scores from the MAP academic assessment.
Consistent gains across schools and grade levels
About 800 schools in the study required students to store their phones in lockable pouches during the school day, while approximately 3,800 schools had no comparable restrictions. Researchers compared academic performance before and after the pouch policies were introduced.
Schools with mandatory phone pouches recorded annual achievement gains 0.01 standard deviations higher than schools without the restrictions. Researchers translated that difference into roughly one to two additional weeks of learning per year, or about two extra minutes of productive learning per class.
Improvements appeared during the first year of implementation and continued for as long as four years in some school districts. Similar results were found across elementary, middle and high schools, as well as in both wealthy and low-income communities.
The researchers also examined statewide phone restrictions and found comparable academic benefits, suggesting that the results were not limited to schools using specialized storage pouches.
Phone restrictions spread across the United States
Among the 44 states included in the analysis, approximately half had introduced school phone restrictions by the 2025-26 academic year. Policies varied, ranging from requiring students to keep phones in their backpacks to using locked pouches or having teachers collect devices at the beginning of the school day.
In 2025, 17 states, including New York, had policies prohibiting student phone use throughout the school day, from arrival until dismissal. Harvard researcher Thomas Kane estimated that dedicated storage pouches cost schools approximately $25 per student.
Could phone bans reverse years of declining achievement?
The findings come amid broader concerns about declining academic performance among American students. Kane previously analyzed National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) results and estimated that students lost the equivalent of two to three weeks of learning annually between 2013 and 2020.
His analysis found that eighth-grade mathematics and reading achievement fell by approximately one full grade level between 2013 and 2024. That period coincided with the rapid expansion of smartphone ownership among teenagers: fewer than 25% had access to smartphones in 2011, compared with 95% in 2018.
Researchers estimate that school-day phone restrictions could potentially offset about half of the annual learning losses dating back to around 2013. Kane cautioned, however, that the new study does not conclusively establish that relationship.
He identified two other possible contributors to declining performance: reduced school accountability tied to standardized test results following changes to the No Child Left Behind Act, and students' social media use outside school. Researchers also said they have yet to explain why the lowest-performing students experienced particularly sharp declines.
Findings differ from earlier research
The Harvard study's conclusions contrast with a large-scale study published earlier this year by researchers from Stanford University and several other institutions. That research found no clear evidence of significant academic improvements at schools using phone-storage pouches, prompting its authors to caution against broad conclusions.
The differing findings highlight the continuing debate over whether restricting smartphones in schools can meaningfully improve academic outcomes. The Harvard-led research suggests that consistent restrictions may deliver modest but sustained gains across a wide range of schools.
Comments
Post a Comment